When Smoking Ribs Which Side Goes Down

When Smoking Ribs Which Side Goes Down? (Solved!)

Imagine you’re playing a game of basketball. You wouldn’t chuck the ball without aiming for the hoop, right? In the same way, when you’re about to smoke ribs, you need to know how to place them in the smoker.

That’s the “hoop” in our BBQ game. And the big question we’re asking is, “When smoking ribs, which side goes down?”

Well, when smoking ribs, it is recommended to place them bone-side down on the grill grates or in the smoker. This allows the heat to circulate evenly around the meat and helps to retain its moisture, resulting in tender and flavorful ribs.

In this article, we’ll look at both sides of the argument i.e. bone-side down vs bone-side up to determine which is the best when smoking ribs.

Let’s begin!

When Smoking Ribs Which Side Goes Down (Overview)

[table id=43 /]


The Anatomy of Ribs

Picture ribs as the star quarterback of the great BBQ game.

Without them, we wouldn’t really have a match, would we? They’re kind of like your favorite action figures – each one has its unique structure and characteristics that make it special.

Let’s get our hands dirty and dive into what makes ribs tick!

Ribs are like a well-organized bookshelf. Have you noticed how books stay upright and in place thanks to the sturdy shelves supporting them?

Similarly, ribs have their very own support system – the curved bones. Nestled between these bones, you’ll find succulent meat, all lined up, ready for the grill.

Let’s Talk About the Meat and the Membrane

On one side, you’ve got the meaty side, which is, drumroll, please… the star of our show! It’s where all the flavorful, tender, juicy meat resides.

It’s the meat that soaks up all our marinades, rubs, and smoke, making your taste buds do a happy dance!

But flip the script, and you have the membrane side of the ribs. This part might seem like a tough cookie to bite into.

But guess what?

It has its role in the BBQ show. You see, this membrane, also known as the rib’s silver skin, helps keep the whole shebang together while our ribs are slow-cooking over smoky heat.

It’s not the hero we see, but definitely the one we need!

Understanding this dynamic duo of the meaty side and the membrane side is your first step towards being a pro in smoking ribs. 

The Great Debate: When Smoking Ribs, Which Side Goes Down

Imagine two groups of friends arguing about who the strongest superhero is. It’s an endless debate with compelling arguments on both sides, right?

Well, the BBQ world has its own version of this. The bone side down camp vs. the bone side up camp.

Picture them, aprons on, BBQ tools in hand, defending their rib smoking style!

Bone Side Down: The Heat Shield Theory

First up, we’ve got the folks from the bone side down town. Now, they swear by smoking ribs with the bones acting as a barrier between the heat and the meat.

Their logic?

Well, the bones, according to them, serve as a heat shield. They’re like the Captain America of the rib world, protecting the precious meat from the villainous overcooking.

Think about how an umbrella shields you from getting drenched in a sudden downpour.

The bones work similarly, taking on the brunt of the heat and saving the tender meat from drying out. Clever, right?

Bone Side Up: The Flavor Basking Approach

On the flip side, we’ve got the bone side up believers.

Now, these guys see things a little differently. They argue that the meat should face the heat.

Why, you ask?

They believe this allows the meat to fully soak in all that smoky, mouthwatering flavor, just like a sponge soaking up water.

It’s like how sunflowers always face the sun, turning as the sun moves across the sky, absorbing as much sunlight as they can.

These BBQ lovers say that smoking the ribs bone side up lets the meat bask in the delicious smoky goodness, absorbing every bit of that flavor.

So, we’re left with a big, smoky question mark. When smoking ribs, which side goes down? Let’s dive deeper and try to crack this BBQ mystery! 

The Impact of Rib Orientation on Smoking

Think of your smoker as a magical cooking arena, where the slow dance between heat, smoke, and meat takes place.

The way you set the stage – or rather, place your ribs – can influence the dance’s rhythm and final result.

Heat Distribution and Rib Orientation: A Balancing Act

When we smoke ribs, we’re doing a kind of slow-cooking ballet, where we use indirect heat to gently coax the flavors out of the meat.

It’s not unlike when you’re toasting marshmallows over a campfire. You don’t put them directly in the flames, do you?

You keep them a bit away, rotating them slowly for that perfect golden-brown toast.

Similarly, the position of your ribs – bone side up or down – can change how the heat kisses the meat. Picture the bones as tiny little see-saws.

When they’re down, they lift the meat a bit, letting the heat circulate underneath. But when they’re up, the meat is in direct contact with the heat.

So, the way you position your ribs might just be the secret ingredient to evenly cooked, mouth-watering BBQ.

The Role of Rib Orientation in Flavor Absorption

Let’s talk about flavor now – the heart and soul of any BBQ!

Just like how a sponge quickly soaks up a juice spill, the meat absorbs the smoke during the smoking process, giving it that drool-worthy, smoky BBQ flavor.

Now, picture this. You’re at a concert, and your favorite band is playing.

If you’re standing right in front of the stage, you’ll feel every beat, every note, won’t you?

But if you’re way at the back, it won’t be the same. Similarly, how the ribs face in the smoker might affect how much of the smoky goodness they soak up.

If the meaty side is facing up, it’s like it’s front-row at the smoke concert, absorbing all the flavor notes.

But if it’s the bone side up, the meat’s at the back, and it might not catch all the smoky tunes.

The Role of the Smoker Type

When Smoking Ribs Which Side Goes Down

Choosing a smoker for your BBQ adventure is like choosing a car.

They all get you from point A to point B, but the journey can be different – some cars are manual, some are automatic, and each has its unique quirks and features.

Offset Smokers

Picture the sun setting, casting long shadows, and its warm glow hitting you from the side. That’s how the heat in an offset smoker works.

It comes from a firebox attached to the side, kind of like a buddy providing support. Because the heat source is not directly under the ribs, it allows for that slow, indirect heat we want for smoking.

Vertical (Bullet) Smokers

Ever watched a hot air balloon rise? Vertical or bullet smokers work on a similar principle. Heat in these smokers moves upwards from the bottom, wrapping your ribs in a warm embrace.

They’re compact, easy to use, and can give you a flavorful payoff.

Kamado Smokers

Imagine wrapping yourself in a cozy blanket on a cold day, feeling warm all over. That’s the kind of heat distribution you get with a Kamado smoker.

These egg-shaped beauties are known for their excellent heat retention and regulation. Whether it’s bone side up or down, your ribs will get an even heat bath in a Kamado.

Pellet Smokers

Remember how your thermostat at home keeps things just right, so you don’t have to worry about it? Pellet smokers are like the thermostats of the BBQ world.

These are the automatic cars of smoking – they control the temperature for you. Just set the desired heat level, and you’re good to go!

Remember, the type of smoker you choose can influence your rib smoking adventure. It can shape how you play with heat and smoke, adding another layer of creativity to your BBQ masterpiece!

Experiment: Comparing Results with Different Rib Orientations

BBQ is not just about the cooking; it’s also about the experimenting, just like in a science lab. You put on your apron, set up your equipment, and try different things to see what happens.

To solve our great debate – bone side down or up – we turned our backyard into a BBQ laboratory.

Setup and Procedure

Our experiment was pretty simple, yet exciting, just like those volcano projects in science class. We got two sets of ribs, prepped them in the same way with the same seasoning, and then placed them in the smoker.

One set was bone side down (our umbrella theory), and the other was bone side up (our sunflower theory).

We kept a keen eye on the temperature and the cooking time, making sure everything was identical for both sets.

Findings and Analysis

The moment of truth felt like Christmas morning, shaking a present and trying to guess what’s inside. When we took out the ribs and started tasting, we found some exciting results.

Overall, the bone-side down ribs were juicier than their bone-side up counterparts. Additionally, they were more tender and flavorful. 

In the world of BBQ, every experiment, every change, brings new flavors and discoveries. Our experiment was no different. It’s proof that BBQ is not just a culinary art, but a delicious science as well.

Expert Tips on Rib Smoking Regardless of Orientation

When Smoking Ribs Which Side Goes Down

Whether the bone side is facing the sky or the coals, there are several key elements to smoking ribs that make all the difference.

They’re like the ingredients in a secret sauce or the magical incantations in a wizard’s spellbook.

Importance of the Right Temperature

No matter which side of the rib orientation debate you stand on, the temperature is always critical, just like the right oven temperature for baking cookies.

Too high and the ribs dry out, too low and they won’t cook thoroughly.

It’s a little like Goldilocks – you need it to be just right.

Most pitmasters would tell you to aim for a smoker temperature of around 225 degrees Fahrenheit. It’s the sweet spot that gives your ribs the perfect tenderness.

Choosing the Right Wood for Smoke Flavor

Selecting the right wood for smoking is another crucial step in your BBQ journey.

It’s like choosing between chocolate and strawberry ice cream – both are delicious, but they offer completely different flavors.

Hardwoods like hickory, oak, and maple can impart a strong flavor, while fruitwoods like apple and cherry give a milder, sweeter taste.

It’s all about your personal preference, and perhaps, the mood of the day.

The Art of Seasoning: Dry Rub vs Marinade

Seasoning is the fairy dust that transforms plain meat into a tantalizing meal. It’s like the battle of superheroes, dry rub vs. marinade.

Both are capable of fantastic feats of flavor, but they do it in different ways.

Dry rub, a mixture of spices and herbs, is rubbed onto the ribs before smoking, just like putting sunscreen before hitting the beach.

On the other hand, marinade, a liquid concoction, requires the ribs to take a flavorful bath before they hit the smoker. It’s up to you to choose your champion.

To Wrap or Not to Wrap: The Foil Debate

Finally, there’s the foil question. It’s like deciding whether to wear a raincoat on a drizzly day. Wrapping your ribs in foil, often referred to as the “Texas Crutch,” can speed up cooking and lock in juices.

However, going foil-free, or “naked,” as some pitmasters prefer to call it, can give your ribs a firmer texture and a bolder bark.

Like every other step in your BBQ adventure, the choice is yours!

Other Factors to Consider When Smoking Ribs

There’s a whole lot more to smoking ribs than simply deciding which side goes down. It’s like being a detective, piecing together the clues to solve the tasty mystery of perfect ribs.

Type of Ribs: Baby Back vs St. Louis Style vs Spare Ribs

You know how in video games you get to choose your character, each with their own special skills and abilities? Well, it’s kind of like that with ribs too.

There are different types of ribs, each with its own size, meatiness, and flavor profile.

  • Baby Back Ribs are like the sprinters, they’re smaller and cook faster, with a sweet, tender meat that’s loved by many.
  • St. Louis Style Ribs are the middle ground, larger than baby backs, well-marbled, and full of flavor – they’re the marathon runners.
  • Then there are Spare Ribs, they’re the heavy lifters, bigger, meatier, and with a more robust flavor.

Managing Time and Temperature: The 3-2-1 Method

Smoking ribs is a slow and delicate process, kind of like growing a bonsai tree or building a sandcastle, you can’t rush it.

And here’s where the 3-2-1 method comes in, it’s like a game plan for smoking ribs.

This method stands for 3 hours of smoking the ribs directly on the rack, then 2 hours of cooking the ribs wrapped in foil (remember our foil debate?), and finally 1 hour of finishing them off unwrapped at a higher temperature to get that beautiful, caramelized finish.

It’s like a roadmap to rib heaven.

The Role of Resting: Patience is Key

Patience is the final ingredient in smoking ribs.

Just like letting a cake cool before you frost it, or waiting for paint to dry before adding another coat, you need to let your ribs rest after they’ve been smoked.

This allows the juices to redistribute throughout the meat, making it even more mouth-wateringly delicious.

As the saying goes, “Good things come to those who wait.” So after all that work, give your ribs the break they deserve. You’ll thank yourself when you take that first bite.

When Smoking Ribs Which Side Goes Down (Final Thoughts)

Personally, I prefer when my ribs are bone-side down. I just find that they are juicier and tender that way.

However, that isn’t to say that the bone-side up option isn’t good. I would advise conducting an experiment similar to the one we did and making a conclusion for yourself.

After all, bbq is all about experimenting and analyzing the results. 

Recommended Articles:

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Should the membrane always be removed before smoking?

Well, the answer isn’t black and white, kind of like deciding between chocolate or vanilla ice cream – it all comes down to personal preference. The membrane on the back of ribs is like a thin sheet of plastic wrap, it can be tough and chewy when cooked. Most pitmasters suggest removing it for a more tender, fall-off-the-bone result. However, if you like a bit of chewiness to your ribs, feel free to leave it on. Some folks also believe that leaving it on helps to keep the ribs moist during smoking. So, it’s up to you, but if you decide to remove it, just get a grip on the corner with a paper towel and pull it off.

Is it necessary to flip the ribs during smoking?

Think about it like sunbathing. You want an even tan, right? So you flip. It’s kind of the same with ribs. Many BBQ experts recommend flipping the ribs at least once during the smoking process to ensure even cooking and color. But don’t go overboard, you’re not making pancakes! Too much flipping can cause the ribs to dry out or cook unevenly. A good rule of thumb is to flip them halfway through the cooking time.

Can I smoke different types of ribs together?

Sure, you can smoke different types of ribs together, just like having a party with friends from different schools. But remember, just like your friends, each type of rib is unique. Baby Backs, St. Louis Style, and Spare Ribs, they all have different cooking times due to their size and thickness. It’s like cooking a bunch of different cookies – some may be done before the others. So you might need to add or remove them at different times to make sure each type is cooked to perfection.

What should be the internal temperature of properly smoked ribs?

The perfect internal temperature for smoked ribs is like the sweet spot in baseball, it’s just right. You’re aiming for around 190 to 205 degrees Fahrenheit (88 to 96 degrees Celsius). At this temperature, the collagen within the ribs has broken down, making the meat tender and delicious. It’s kind of like turning a hard candy into a gooey, melty delight.

How to keep ribs moist during a long smoking session?

Keeping ribs moist during a long smoking session is like taking care of a pet – it needs constant attention. One trick is to spray or mop your ribs with a liquid, like apple juice or a vinegar-based mop sauce, every hour or so. This helps to keep the surface of the meat moist. Another tip is the “Texas Crutch,” where you wrap the ribs in foil with a little liquid after a few hours of smoking. It’s like giving your ribs a cozy, steamy blanket that keeps them moist and speeds up cooking. Just be sure to unwrap them for the last hour to get that beautiful, smoky bark.


As a passionate enthusiast of smoking, grilling, and BBQ, Mark has dedicated his life to perfecting the art of outdoor cooking. With over a decade of experience in the field, he has honed his expertise and authority on all things related to meat smoking, grilling, and BBQ. From mastering the perfect cut of meat to choosing the right wood for the smoker, Mark has the knowledge and experience to help you become a pro at outdoor cooking.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *