Oklahoma Joe Bronco Vs Weber Smokey Mountain

Oklahoma Joe Bronco Vs Weber Smokey Mountain (Compared!)

Oklahoma Joe Bronco vs Weber Smokey Mountain, which is better?

When I was looking for a smoker, I had a hard time deciding between the Oklahoma Joe Bronco and the Weber Smokey Mountain. I ultimately went with the Weber Smokey Mountain and it has been good so far.

However, before picking one, I had to do a lot of research looking at the features, performance, and so on. I talked to people who had experience with either of these smokers and I gathered a lot of information.

So in this article, I’d like to share what I found when comparing the Oklahoma Joe Bronco vs Weber Smokey Mountain so you can make a decision for yourself. 

Let’s dive in!

The Oklahoma Joe Bronco

Oklahoma Joe Bronco Vs Weber Smokey Mountain


During my research, I discovered that the Oklahoma Joe Bronco is quite popular among backyard pitmasters. 

With its robust construction and striking design, it demands attention from all who pass by.

This beast of a smoker boasts ample cooking space, allowing you to effortlessly cater to large gatherings or satisfy your own insatiable appetite for smoked delicacies.

But it’s not just about looks! The Oklahoma Joe Bronco delivers exceptional performance as well.

Equipped with multiple air vents strategically placed around its cylindrical body, this smoker offers precise control over airflow and temperature regulation.

No matter if you’re smoking low ‘n slow or searing hot ‘n fast, the Bronco has got your back.

However, honestly speaking, compared to the WSM, I found fewer people who had experience with this smoker. Regardless, they all had good things to say about it. 

Weber Smokey Mountain

Oklahoma Joe Bronco Vs Weber Smokey Mountain

When it comes to smokers that have stood the test of time, few can rival the legendary Weber Smokey Mountain (or WSM for short). In fact, that’s why I eventually picked it over the OJB. 

This charcoal-fueled wonder has been gracing backyards for decades and has become synonymous with top-notch barbecue.

I was able to get tons of people who had experience using this smoker and everyone had only good things to say about it. 

One look at the Weber Smokey Mountain and you’ll understand why it has such a devoted following.

Its distinctive bullet-shaped design is not just visually appealing; it’s engineered to ensure even heat distribution throughout the cooking chamber.

The result? Consistently succulent, mouthwatering meats that will make you the grill hero among your friends and family.

The Popularity Contest

Both Oklahoma Joe Bronco and Weber Smokey Mountain have amassed quite a fan base over the years, garnering loyal followers in the world of smoking enthusiasts. 

And it’s no wonder why – these brands have earned their reputation through quality craftsmanship, reliable performance, and exceptional flavor delivery.

Oklahoma Joe Bronco has gained recognition for its innovative features that enhance user experience, such as its unique airflow control system and a convenient heat deflector.

On the other hand, Weber Smokey Mountain’s enduring popularity is due to its traditional approach, coupled with thoughtful details like its adjustable dampers and easy-access doors for hassle-free cooking.

So here we stand at the crossroads of two smoking titans.

In the following sections, we’ll take a deep dive into their features, performance, versatility, maintenance requirements, pricing options, user reviews – everything you need to make an informed decision about which smoker will be your ultimate grilling companion.

Oklahoma Joe Bronco Vs Weber Smokey Mountain (General Comparison)

Size and capacity 

When it comes to size, the Oklahoma Joe Bronco and the Weber Smokey Mountain have distinct differences. 

The Bronco is a barrel-style smoker, measuring 43.3 inches in height with a diameter of 25.4 inches. This gives it a generous cooking space of around 284 square inches. 

On the other hand, the Weber Smokey Mountain comes in three sizes: 14-inch, 18-inch, and 22-inch models. 

The largest of the three provides an ample cooking area of approximately 726 square inches. 

So if you are looking for greater cooking capacity, the Smokey Mountain would be your go-to choice. 

Construction materials 

Both smokers are built to withstand the test of time but employ different materials in their construction.

The Oklahoma Joe Bronco features heavy-gauge steel construction that ensures durability and excellent heat retention.

 Its sturdy design contributes to its impressive temperature control capabilities.

In contrast, the Weber Smokey Mountain is known for its robust build using porcelain-enameled steel material. 

This not only enhances its longevity but also aids in maintaining consistent temperatures throughout your cooking process.

Oklahoma Joe Bronco Vs Weber Smokey Mountain (Weight and Portability Factors)

When considering portability, weight plays a significant role for those who plan on transporting their smokers frequently or need them for tailgating adventures. 

The Oklahoma Joe Bronco weighs around 136 pounds due to its solid steel construction which adds to its stable nature but may compromise ease of transportability.

On the other hand, while it is slightly heavier than its counterpart, the Weber Smokey Mountain offers greater portability due to its compact design and easily detachable parts (such as the lid, body, and fuel door). This feature allows for effortless transportation when needed.

Moreover, the Smokey Mountain’s handles are ergonomically designed for comfortable lifting. When considering size and capacity, the Weber Smokey Mountain offers more cooking space options compared to the Oklahoma Joe Bronco.

However, if durability and heavy-gauge steel construction are your priorities, then the Bronco might be a better choice. 

When it comes to portability, though slightly heavier, the Smokey Mountain’s detachable parts and convenient handles make it a more suitable option for those who need to move their smoker around frequently.

Watch this:


Temperature Control

When it comes to controlling the temperature in your smoker, I found that both the Oklahoma Joe Bronco and Weber Smokey Mountain provide effective methods. However, they differ in their approaches. The Weber Smokey Mountain uses a water pan system, which is a tried and true method for heat regulation.

By filling the water pan with liquid, such as water or apple juice, you can create a moist environment inside the smoker. This moisture helps regulate the temperature by absorbing and releasing heat slowly.

Additionally, it adds moisture to your food, resulting in juicy and tender meat. On the other hand, the Oklahoma Joe Bronco takes a different approach with its multiple air vents for precise airflow control.

These vents give you more control over both the amount of air coming into the smoker and how it circulates inside. 

By adjusting these vents strategically, you can increase or decrease airflow to raise or lower the temperature accordingly.

This feature is particularly helpful when cooking different types of meat that require specific temperatures. 

Whether you’re smoking ribs low and slow or searing steaks at high heat, having precise control over airflow allows you to achieve optimal results every time.

Weber Smokey Mountain’s Water Pan System For Heat Regulation

The Weber Smokey Mountain relies on its innovative water pan system for efficient heat regulation during smoking sessions. 

Located between charcoal grates and cooking grates, this water pan serves multiple purposes when it comes to maintaining an ideal cooking environment.

Firstly, it acts as a heat sink by absorbing some of the excess heat produced by burning charcoal briquettes or wood chips.

As a result, this creates a buffer zone that prevents sudden temperature spikes while providing consistent cooking conditions.

Furthermore, this water pan generates steam as it interacts with intense heat from below during operation. 

The rising steam helps keep the internal temperature steady, preventing excessive drying out of your food.

Additionally, when combined with flavorful liquids like fruit juice or beer, the water pan imparts a gentle, aromatic steam to your meat, enhancing its taste and tenderness. By replenishing the water as needed throughout the cooking process, you can ensure a moist and succulent outcome for each dish.

Oklahoma Joe Bronco’s Multiple Air Vents For Precise Airflow Control

In contrast to the Weber Smokey Mountain’s water pan system, the Oklahoma Joe Bronco employs a different technique for temperature control through its cleverly designed multiple air vents. 

These strategically placed vents allow you to fine-tune the airflow inside the smoker according to your specific cooking requirements.

By adjusting these vents open or closed, you gain precise control over how much oxygen reaches the fire and how smoke circulates within the cooking chamber. 

By opening all the vents wide open, you can achieve high temperatures suitable for searing steaks or creating a crispy bark on your barbecue.

Conversely, by closing most of the vents partially or completely, you restrict oxygen flow and lower the temperature for slow smoking large cuts of meat. 

The ability to customize airflow in this manner ensures that you have complete control over both heat distribution and smoke intensity throughout your cooking process.

Ultimately, both smokers offer effective temperature control methods. 

The Weber Smokey Mountain leverages its water pan system to provide consistent heat regulation with added moisture for juicy results.

Meanwhile, Oklahoma Joe Bronco’s multiple air vents offer unparalleled precision in manipulating airflow to achieve optimal temperatures based on your specific culinary needs. 

When choosing between these two options, consider which method aligns best with your preferred smoking techniques and desired outcomes.

Oklahoma Joe Bronco Vs Weber Smokey Mountain (Cooking Performance)

When it comes to cooking performance, the heat distribution efficiency of a smoker plays a crucial role in achieving mouthwatering results. 

Both the Oklahoma Joe Bronco and the Weber Smokey Mountain excel in their own unique ways.

Let’s dive into their respective heating capabilities.

Weber Smokey Mountain’s bullet-shaped design for even heat circulation

The Weber Smokey Mountain, often lovingly referred to as the “WSM,” boasts a bullet-shaped design that is specifically engineered for exceptional heat circulation. 

This shape allows the smoke and heat to swirl around inside, creating an environment that promotes even cooking throughout the entire chamber. 

No hot or cold spots here!

The WSM’s ingenious design results in consistent temperatures across its multiple cooking levels. 

Whether you’re smoking succulent ribs on one level or slow-cooking a tender brisket on another, you can trust that the Weber Smokey Mountain will evenly distribute heat, ensuring perfectly cooked barbecue every time.

Watch this:



Oklahoma Joe Bronco’s Reverse Flow Technology For Consistent Cooking Results

Meanwhile, the Oklahoma Joe Bronco takes a slightly different approach with its innovative reverse flow technology. 

This sophisticated system ensures unparalleled consistency and uniformity when it comes to cooking your favorite cuts of meat.

In simple terms, reverse flow means that smoke and heat enter from one side of the smoker and then travel underneath a metal plate before rising again through strategically placed vents on the opposite side. 

This creates an indirect flow of smoke and temperature that envelops your food with even precision.

Thanks to its ingenious engineering, the Oklahoma Joe Bronco delivers excellent thermal conductivity throughout its cooking chamber. 

You won’t have to worry about cold spots ruining your masterpiece; instead, you’ll enjoy consistent cooking results from corner to corner.

So as you can see, both smokers have their unique methods of achieving exceptional heat distribution. 

The Weber Smokey Mountain’s bullet-shaped design and the Oklahoma Joe Bronco’s reverse flow technology are both highly effective in ensuring that your food cooks evenly, leaving you with a mouthwatering and satisfying barbecue experience.

Oklahoma Joe Bronco Vs Weber Smokey Mountain (Versatility Features)

When it comes to versatility, both the Oklahoma Joe Bronco and Weber Smokey Mountain smokers have some impressive features to offer. 

The Weber Smokey Mountain boasts a built-in thermometer, allowing you to monitor the temperature without needing an additional gadget.

This convenient addition ensures that you can keep a close eye on your cooking progress without any guesswork or constant peeking. 

On the other hand, the Oklahoma Joe Bronco takes versatility up a notch with adjustable charcoal grate positions.

This feature gives you more control over heat management, allowing you to customize your smoking experience based on different recipes and personal preferences. 

Additionally, the removable ash pan makes cleaning up a breeze, simplifying maintenance tasks and providing convenience that every pitmaster desires.

Oklahoma Joe Bronco Vs Weber Smokey Mountain (Maintenance and Durability)

When it comes to maintenance and durability, both smokers have their own strengths. 

I’ve found that the Weber Smokey Mountain is easy-to-clean because of its porcelain-enameled surfaces. 

These surfaces are designed specifically to resist sticking and facilitate effortless cleanup.

With just a few wipes or gentle scrubbing, you can keep your Weber smoker looking pristine after every use. 

Meanwhile, the Oklahoma Joe Bronco stands out with its removable ash pan feature.

This innovation allows for convenient ash disposal, saving you time and effort in cleaning up after each smoking session.

Simply remove the ash pan, empty it into a designated area (such as your compost bin), and put it back in place for hassle-free maintenance.

Oklahoma Joe Bronco Vs Weber Smokey Mountain (Price Range and Value)

Now let’s dive into price range and value comparison between these two smokers. 

The Weber Smokey Mountain generally falls into a more affordable price range compared to the Oklahoma Joe Bronco.

In fact, this was a major factor in me choosing the WSM over the OJB. 

The WSM offers excellent value for budget-conscious individuals who are seeking a reliable, high-quality smoker without breaking the bank. 

On the other end of the spectrum, the Oklahoma Joe Bronco is considered a higher-end investment due to its added features and superior build quality.

If you’re looking for advanced features and enhanced durability, the Bronco justifies its higher price point. 

This smoker caters to serious barbecue enthusiasts who want exceptional performance and long-term value.

Final Thoughts

Comparing the Oklahoma Joe Bronco and Weber Smokey Mountain smokers reveals two remarkable options for achieving delicious smoked dishes at home. 

While the Weber Smokey Mountain stands out as an affordable choice with handy features like built-in thermometers and easy-to-clean surfaces, the Oklahoma Joe Bronco takes versatility to another level with adjustable charcoal grate positions and a convenient removable ash pan. 

Considering factors like maintenance requirements and longevity, each smoker has distinct advantages: porcelain-enameled surfaces make cleaning effortless in the case of Weber Smokey Mountain, while Oklahoma Joe Bronco’s removable ash pan simplifies ash disposal.

Moreover, the price difference leans in favor of the Weber Smokey Mountain as a budget-friendly option, while the Oklahoma Joe Bronco justifies its higher price with added features and durability. 

Ultimately, the choice between these two smokers depends on individual preferences, cooking needs, and budget considerations.

Whichever smoker you opt for, rest assured that both offer exceptional smoking experiences that will elevate your culinary journey to new smoky heights. 

Related Articles:



Which is better, Weber kettle or Smokey Mountain?

The choice between a Weber kettle and a Smokey Mountain depends on your preferences and cooking style. The Weber kettle is versatile, suitable for grilling and smoking, while the Smokey Mountain is designed specifically for smoking. Consider your cooking needs and space when deciding.

Can you use a Weber Smokey Mountain as a BBQ?

Yes, you can use a Weber Smokey Mountain as both a smoker and a BBQ. It’s designed to provide excellent smoking capabilities, but you can also use it for direct grilling by placing the cooking grates directly above the charcoal. This versatility makes it suitable for various cooking styles.

How long can you smoke on Weber Smokey Mountain?

The smoking time on a Weber Smokey Mountain depends on factors like the type of meat, temperature, and desired level of smokiness. Generally, a smoking session can last anywhere from a few hours to several hours. Regularly monitor the charcoal and water levels to maintain consistent heat and smoke.

What Weber is best for smoking?

The Weber Smokey Mountain (WSM) series is specifically designed for smoking and is highly regarded by smoking enthusiasts. It comes in different sizes, allowing you to choose the one that suits your needs. The WSM’s excellent insulation and airflow control make it a reliable choice for achieving consistent smoking results.


As a passionate enthusiast of smoking, grilling, and BBQ, Mark has dedicated his life to perfecting the art of outdoor cooking. With over a decade of experience in the field, he has honed his expertise and authority on all things related to meat smoking, grilling, and BBQ. From mastering the perfect cut of meat to choosing the right wood for the smoker, Mark has the knowledge and experience to help you become a pro at outdoor cooking.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *