Is Brisket Safe At 175

Is Brisket Safe At 175? (Everything You Need To Know!)

Have you ever thought about that delicious slab of brisket on your grill and wondered, “Is Brisket Safe At 175 degrees?” If so, you’ve come to the right place. 

While brisket can technically be safe to eat at 175°F, it’s usually not the ideal temperature for a tender and juicy brisket. Most BBQ enthusiasts and chefs recommend cooking brisket until it reaches an internal temperature of 195-203°F to achieve optimal tenderness.

As someone who spends most of their time grilling, I know how hard it can be to summon the patience to wait more than 10 hours for brisket to be done.

However, it’s something you must do if you want a perfectly cooked brisket at the end of the day. 

A lot of people that I’ve come across wonder if brisket is safe at 175 so in this article, we will determine the pros and cons of having brisket at 175.

Let’s begin!

Ever wondered why your brisket gets done too early and how to rescue it? Explore our comprehensive guide for all the answers!

Understanding Brisket: The Lowdown

Cooking brisket may seem like a Herculean task, but trust me, it’s not as complicated as it sounds.

Sure, it’s not as simple as slapping a burger on the grill, but it’s nowhere near as mind-boggling as quantum physics either.

I’d say it’s more like solving a fun puzzle, one where the pieces are different cooking elements, and the picture you’re trying to make is a mouth-watering masterpiece of a meal.

Okay, here’s the lowdown: When you cook a brisket, it’s all about the chemistry between heat and the proteins in the meat.

Picture this – the heat is like a superhero, and the tough proteins are like the villains. The heat swoops in, and the epic battle begins!

This clash of the titans breaks down the tough proteins, transforming what was once chewy and tough into a succulent, melt-in-your-mouth banquet.

But hang on, there’s a twist!

This isn’t a reckless brawl, it’s a calculated dance, a balancing act if you will.

If our superhero, the heat, goes too gung-ho, the brisket could end up like a blackened rock, charred and inedible.

And if our heat warrior is too gentle, the proteins won’t break down enough and you’ll be chewing till the cows come home!

The Perfect Temperature – Treading a Fine Line

Finding the perfect temperature to cook your brisket is like finding the sweet spot in a game of baseball.

It has to be just right.

Too high, and you’ll strike out with a burnt brisket; too low, and you’ll have to wrestle with a tough slab of meat.

It’s all about getting that perfect pitch, hitting that home run and making the crowd – in this case, your taste buds – go wild!

The Magic Number: 175 Degrees

So, why do I call 175 degrees the magic number, you ask?

Well, it’s like the key that opens the door to brisket paradise.

Some chefs and food aficionados will tell you that it’s the sweet spot where the tough brisket begins to turn into tender gold.

But hold your horses!

While it’s true that the journey of transformation begins around this temperature, it doesn’t mean your brisket is ready to waltz onto your plate just yet.

The Reality Check: Is 175 Degrees Safe?

Now let’s put on our detective hats and investigate this 175-degree conundrum a bit further.

Visualize a rollercoaster ride – you know, the one that starts off slow and then throws you into a wild loop.

That’s what’s happening to the meat fibers in your brisket at around 175 degrees.

They’re beginning to break down, sure, but they’re not quite at the point of being fully tender and perfectly edible.

And here’s another curveball for you – at 175 degrees, you might still be dancing on thin ice.

You see, undercooked meat can be a breeding ground for harmful bacteria. It’s like inviting unwanted guests to your party – nobody wants that!

Always remember, it’s safety first when it comes to cooking.

You wouldn’t want to dive into a pool before it’s filled with water, would you?

Likewise, you don’t want to bite into your brisket before it’s fully cooked.

There’s a temperature range, often referred to as the ‘safe zone‘, where your brisket is not just cooked, but perfectly safe to eat.

So, hold on to your horses and let’s learn about this ‘safe zone’ in the next chapter.

The Official Word: USDA Guidelines

Ever wondered what the big kahuna, the USDA, has to say about this meaty mystery?

Well, it’s their job to lay down the law when it comes to all things food-related.

According to them, brisket should reach an internal temperature of a whopping 195 degrees to be deemed safe to eat.

Yeah, you heard that right, it’s a whole 20 degrees hotter than our earlier magic number of 175 degrees.

It’s like wearing both a belt and suspenders to keep your pants up – you know, taking that extra step to make sure everything is hunky-dory.

Better safe than sorry, right?

Now, what if you decide to buck the trend and settle for a brisket cooked only to 175 degrees?

Well, my friend, brace yourself, because you’re in for a rough ride.

Apart from the obvious safety risks – which we definitely don’t want to gamble with – there’s the whole issue of taste and texture.

Trying to gnaw on an undercooked brisket is like trying to chew on an old, worn-out boot.

It’s tough, dry, and let’s be honest, it’s not exactly the belle of the barbecue ball, is it?

Imagine biting into a slice of brisket expecting a flavor explosion, but instead, you’re left wrestling with a piece of meat that’s as stubborn as a mule.

Not the ideal guest at your backyard barbecue, I’d say!

In the end, undercooking a brisket is like throwing a wrench in the works of your perfectly planned barbecue party.

It doesn’t just put your health at risk, but also takes a swing at your taste buds.

So, let’s not cut corners, okay? Let’s follow the rules, take our time, and aim to hit that USDA recommended 195 degrees.

Overcooking Brisket: The Other Side of the Coin

Let’s put the brakes on that heat dial.

Sure, we’ve made a strong case against undercooking, but going to the other extreme is like jumping out of the frying pan into the fire – you don’t want to do that.

Imagine biting into a slice of brisket, expecting that juicy burst of flavor, but instead, it’s like chewing on a sun-dried tomato.

Not a tasty picture, right?

Overcooking brisket turns it from a delightful feast to a kitchen nightmare. It’s like transforming a juicy peach into a sad, shriveled prune.

You take that tender, flavorful piece of brisket and zap all the life out of it.

The result?

A hunk of meat as dry as the Sahara desert and as crumbly as a sandcastle at high tide. Not exactly the star attraction for your backyard barbecue, is it?

Embracing the Turtle: The Art of Slow Cooking

Now, let’s talk about a different route, one that’s less about speed and more about patience.

Think of slow cooking like you’re the tortoise in the race, not the hare. Slow and steady, that’s the motto.

This isn’t a dash to the finish line, it’s a marathon, where taking your time pays off big time.

So, what’s the deal with slow cooking? It’s like giving your brisket a long, relaxing spa treatment.

You set the temperature low, and let the brisket simmer for hours, letting it soak up all the heat gradually.

This way, it doesn’t just reach the safe temperature, it gets there while retaining all its precious juices.

Alternatives to 175 Degrees

So, we’ve seen that 175 degrees isn’t the golden ticket when it comes to brisket.

Now, you must be wondering, “What’s my next move?” Here’s the keyword for you – adaptability.

Picture yourself as a master chef, adjusting the dial with precision to make your brisket just right.

Now, if you’re dreaming of a brisket that’s so tender it could melt in your mouth, aim for the big 200 – that’s 200 degrees.

It’s like taking a leap from a trampoline, going a bit higher than you’re used to, but the landing is oh-so-smooth!

But, hold your horses! Don’t just crank up the heat and walk away. Keep a close eye on your brisket – you don’t want it turning into a desert, do you?

On the other hand, if you’re a fan of a brisket with a bit more bite to it, you can drop the temperature a bit.

It’s a delicate dance, a bit like juggling. You have to keep all the balls in the air to get it right!

The Magic Wand of Grilling: Meat Thermometer

Now, let’s move onto a nifty little tool that can make your brisket grilling adventures a breeze – the meat thermometer.

Picture yourself as a wizard, and the meat thermometer is your magic wand, helping you cast the perfect spell to make your brisket safe and delicious!

Say goodbye to the wild guesses and crossed fingers, praying that your brisket is cooked just right.

With a meat thermometer, you’ll know exactly when your meat hits the safe zone. It’s like having a superpower that lets you see inside the meat!

Here’s how it works.

Find the thickest part of your brisket, now gently insert the thermometer into it. It’s like putting a key into a lock, opening the door to the world of perfectly cooked brisket.

And there you have it – the temperature of your brisket, no fuss, no muss!

Is Brisket Safe At 175? (Wrapping It Up)

So, let’s get back to the million-dollar question, “Is Brisket Safe At 175?”

In a nutshell, while you can eat brisket at 175 degrees, it might not be the best idea.

Why take a chance when you can have a perfectly safe and delicious brisket by cooking it to the recommended temperature?

Recommended Articles:


What is the ideal internal temperature for brisket?

Well, you’ve hit the bull’s eye with this question! According to the United States Department of Agriculture, the USDA, you should cook your brisket until it reaches an internal temperature of 195 degrees Fahrenheit. Why this particular number, you might wonder? This is the magical point at which the brisket is not only safe to devour but also succulent and full of flavor. Think of it like the finish line in a race, the point where you know you’ve achieved perfection!

What happens if brisket is cooked at a lower temperature?

Now, that’s an intriguing question. If you decide to go lower than the recommended temperature, it’s like taking a shortcut on a hike, you might not get to see the best views! The brisket might turn out undercooked, and it won’t be the tender, melt-in-your-mouth treat you were hoping for. More importantly, it could also pose some health risks as undercooked meat can harbor harmful bacteria. Picture biting into a tough, chewy piece of meat instead of a tender, juicy slice – not the most appetizing image, is it?

Can I eat brisket that has been cooked to 175 degrees?

Sure, you can technically eat brisket cooked to 175 degrees, but it’s a bit like jumping into a pool without checking the water temperature first – it might not be the most pleasant experience. While the meat begins to break down and tenderize at this temperature, it’s not the optimal point for flavor and safety. For a brisket that’s not only safe to eat but also delectably tender, it’s best to stick to the USDA’s recommendation of cooking it until it reaches an internal temperature of 195 degrees. So, next time you’re cooking brisket, remember, patience is a virtue, and good things come to those who wait!


As a passionate enthusiast of smoking, grilling, and BBQ, Mark has dedicated his life to perfecting the art of outdoor cooking. With over a decade of experience in the field, he has honed his expertise and authority on all things related to meat smoking, grilling, and BBQ. From mastering the perfect cut of meat to choosing the right wood for the smoker, Mark has the knowledge and experience to help you become a pro at outdoor cooking.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *